SoundPLAN Info #10                          April 2014

From the Leader in Noise Simulation Software for Transportation/Industry/Aircraft and Indoor Noise

Dear SoundPLAN users and future users,

It's time for another newsletter to help you become more proficient with SoundPLAN, create better investigation models, and get results more quickly. This newsletter's focus is on:

Aircraft Noise Modeling

Modeling a complete airport with take-off and landings, APUs, engine   run-up, taxiing, air conditioning, transportation noise and more         

Feel free to forward the URL or send us e-mail addresses for future newsletters (Register). Or choose to UNSUBSCRIBE

If you have requests for newsletter topics or other suggestions, send us your Feedback.

Register for the SoundPLAN user forum at http://forum.soundplan.eu.

If you are not sure how to use a feature described in this info, please contact your local support hotline for assistance. The links are located to the right.

Previous issues of SoundPLAN Info:

Info #1 in PDF format

Info #2 in PDF format

Info #3 in PDF format

Info #4 in PDF format

Info #5 in PDF format

Info #6 in PDF format

Info #7 in PDF format

Info #8 in PDF format

Info #9 in PDF format

 

Useful links:

Download SoundPLAN

Download SP essential

SoundPLAN website

SoundPLAN USA

SoundPLAN Nord

SoundPLAN UK

SoundPLAN Australia

 

Development office:

SoundPLAN GmbH

Etzwiesenberg 15

D-71522 Backnang

Germany

(0049) 7191 9144-14

 

International marketing:

SoundPLAN International LLC

80 E Aspley Ln

Shelton, WA 98584

(001) 360 432 9840

 

Trading partners:

Please click on the link for details

Argentina

Australia

Brazil

Canada

Chile

China

Colombia

Czech Republic

Denmark, Finland,

Sweden Norway

Iceland

Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia

Arabic countries

France

Germany

Greece

Hungary

Hong Kong & Macao

India

Indonesia

Ireland

Israel

Italy

Japan

Korea

Malaysia

Mexico

Netherlands

New Zealand

Peru

Poland

Portugal

Romania

Russia

Serbia

Singapore

South Africa

Spain

Taiwan

Thailand

Turkey

United Arab Emirates

United Kingdom

United States

Vietnam

Aircraft Noise

Why Aircraft Noise Calculations?

Aircraft noise can be measured and simulated with specialized software like SoundPLAN. Noise monitoring and measurement can only measure the noise that is present. During the planning process for an airport or a new runway, simulations are used for the different scenarios and to evaluate different approach and departure procedures.

Measurements always measure the entire noise environment. It is not possible afterwards to do creative accounting and show that of the 67.5 dB the majority was car traffic and industrial noise and only 61 dB came from flying aircraft. This type of analysis is only possible with simulations.

Simulations are used to study and support a staged pricing structure for landing fees depending on the number of noise exposed persons. If a noisy aircraft wants to land at night, the landing fees should reflect the cost to the population. If a noisy aircraft wants to land, it should cost more than a quiet airplane landing.

Aircraft Noise

Aircraft noise is amongst the most annoying forms of noise! As everyone drives a car or takes a train, these forms of noise are much more willingly accepted by the population. Airports often install noise monitoring stations to produce noise maps as a measure of good will. If complaints are received the airport administration can always say "We are on it!" even if little is actually done.

Worldwide the dominant standard to simulate aircraft noise is the ECAC Doc. 29 3rd edition. In Europe there are some countries that use different forms of the AzB Switzerland also has its own calculation standard. In Australia aircraft noise is evaluated in relation to the ambient noise levels.

 

SoundPLANís Aircraft Noise Module

SoundPLAN 7.3 fully integrates aircraft noise with transportation and industry noise. The calculations are in accordance to the European guideline for the calculation of aircraft noise, the ECAC Doc. 29 2nd edition (which is used as European interim method for noise mapping) and the 3rd edition. ECAC Doc 29 3rd edition is also the basis of the US INM software. As all noise types are in the same suite, it is possible to make a comprehensive noise study with flying aircraft, taxi operations, engine test and run-up, auxiliary power units, baggage handling, air conditioning and transportation noise to and from the airport. As all noise types are in a single software suite there is no friction loss between different software products importing and exporting data and noise maps if you want a full scale noise evaluation.

With the possibility to import the public aircraft library from EUROCONTROL or the library from the American Integrated Noise Model (INM) and using the same algorithms, it becomes easy to calculate comparable results. All the existing tools such as various import and export possibilities, plus many, many GIS-functions to manipulate your data, and an advanced documentation, your work is made easy and efficient. There is no need to work with cryptic online commands to manipulate your data as all tools are embedded in our well-structured user interface.

Noise Contour Maps

The main point of the aircraft noise modeling is to show the noise contours for an existing or planned airport or to show the variations in contours for different operations / plans / future aircraft / noise abatement restrictions and so on.

Parallel to the graphical representation of the noise contours it is possible to get details in tabular form for single receivers and to create Facade Noise Maps, Cross-Sectional Noise Maps and Meshed Maps.

To the left are two examples of noise contour maps the top one is for the AtatŁrk Airport in Istanbul, Turkey, the bottom one is a noise map on the basis of radar tracks for the Hannover, (Germany) airport.

The aircraft noise maps for Turkey were made on behalf of the European Union to introduce Turkey to the European Noise Directive. Amongst the other aircraft noise studies, SoundPLAN was used for the Norah study of the greater Frankfurt area. (NORAH - Study on Noise-Related Annoyance, Cognition and Health). This study compares the noise related influence factors of aircraft noise to those of other noise types for the wider Frankfurt area. The scope of this study involved over 2 million buildings, about 7500 km≤ of terrain and 36 gigabyte of terrain data. To cope with the amount of data, the project was done using SoundPLAN, a GIS system and an Oracle database.

Evaluation of Aircraft Noise Versus Other Types of Noise

The degree to which people in their residence are annoyed by noise depends on the magnitude of the noise level and on the frequency of noise events and the maximum noise level. Psychoacoustic studies have revealed a relationship between the type of noise source, the magnitude of the noise event and the percentage of people who are annoyed or highly annoyed by the noise.

In SoundPLAN aircraft noise and noise from other sources can be evaluated separately and then subjected to the annoyance calculation to pinpoint how many residents are having problems with aircraft noise versus other forms of noise. A Facade Noise Map of residential areas delivers the feed stock of the calculation. It can be undertaken for aircraft noise and all other types of noise separately. In the SoundPLAN Spreadsheet the formulas for % Annoyed (in the yellow box to the left) and % Highly Annoyed will reveal the ratio of people who have a problem with aircraft noise versus other types of noise. A total number of annoyed persons can easily be generated from the data.

The number of annoyed people can be used to run scenarios of aircraft noise in order to find a system of landing fees for noisy aircraft. Itís that easy!

Definition of the Airport, Runways and Flight Track

In SoundPLAN, studying aircraft noise begins by defining the airport with reference points for the runways relative to the airport. The airport to the left is the Hannover airport in Germany, EDDV. The influence radius for aircraft noise is customarily set to 20 km around the airport but simulations can be extended to whatever distance that the noise study requires. The data entry is for the definition in accordance to the AzB. The definition in accordance to ECAC would require additional environmental information. Runways are defined relative to the airport reference point.

Flight tracks are generated for each runway. For the flight tracks, the user must insert operational data of the aircraft type which is linked to an elevation profile and an acoustical profile. These data create the aircraft simulation.

Flight Tracks and Corridors

Flight tracks are usually followed up to a 30 kilometer radius. Aircraft do not follow a road or railway line; they are determined by air traffic control personnel who advise pilots to turn to a specific heading and fly in a certain direction for a specified time. The exact time and turn radius is the pilots discretion and therefore the flight tracks can be described as corridors rather than lines. Flight operations and weather conditions also add to the variability.

Around the airport there are mandatory reporting points, usually associated with a radio beacon that aircraft tend to fly over. For the calculation, the standards determine how the flight corridor is represented by individual line sources.

Tracks and Traffic

Flight tracks are specific to a runway. The tracks consist of the track name, the landing / take off direction, a glide path and the detailed description of the flight path.

The traffic data (how many planes for day/night) are also associated with the flight track.

Normally, commercial aircraft fly using instrument rules, meaning the track is more restricted than when flying with visual flight rules. SoundPLAN allows both IFR and VFR traffic as well as military traffic and helicopter entries.

Radar Tracks - How to Import from Where?

Naturally, SoundPLAN offers the typical approach for noise predictions based on the backbones of idealized flight tracks, which is ideal for future situations. In addition SoundPLAN offers the possibility to calculate noise on the basis of imported radar tracks, which is the most efficient and precise procedure for the analysis of past situations. By using recorded radar tracks it is possible to show noise maps for any single flight, or any user definable time frame.

Radar tracks are recorded as coordinates and time with information about the aircraft type. SoundPLAN not only imports the coordinates and connects them with a straight line, it also interpolates data and if the time discrete polling makes it necessary it even extrapolates the path. Each imported flight path is assigned a specific aircraft and thus elevation profiles and power settings.

In SoundPLAN the module to import and calculate noise levels from recorded radar tracks is an addition to the aircraft noise module.

Even if you do not want to calculate the noise levels directly from recorded radar tracks, they are a useful tool to generate backbones for the regular modeling. As aircraft are not following a singular path but have a variation depending on side wind components, the commands of air traffic control and the exact timing when a turn is initiated, the flight path is rather a corridor than a track. The flight paths are statistically distributed in this corridor. For the calculation this distribution is approximated with multiple flight paths, for the conversion of recorded flight the reverse analogy is also true allowing the program to distill the backbones from the recorded paths.

Elevation Profile

Aircraft libraries set a standard elevation profile over distance from the airport. These profiles reflect the power and flap settings and will also influence the sound power definition for that profile and class of aircraft. The elevation profile depicted with the red dotted line is the elevation profile automatically assigned to the selected flight procedure when importing flights with radar tracks.

 

Noise Level Statistics

Aside from customary noise maps, the noise calculation for single receivers will create a noise level statistics where the distribution of noise events and the type of aircraft are coordinated.

Aircraft Noise with Other Noise Sources

Some noise studies are not just for aircraft noise, but are part of a wider environmental assessment study where all sources are evaluated. SoundPLAN does this by combining individually calculated noise maps for aircraft with maps of other noise sources. In the picture to the left aircraft noise is visible along with noise from taxiing on the ground train noise, the APU and the traffic noise in the community.

In some countries (Australia for example)aircraft noise is not evaluated by itself but in relationship to the background noise levels. This type of scenario is quickly evaluated in SoundPLAN.

 

Sound Power and Directivity

For each aircraft type there is a definition for the sound power over frequency plus the directivity associated with the aircraft. The performance related database can be edited and amended with aircraft not found in the database (experimental or new aircraft). Most standards are delivered with their own aircraft noise and performance database. SoundPLAN can read the standard INM database and allow users to work in accordance to the INM performance database.

 

Moving noise-map of a military jet

With the SoundPLAN calculations of aircraft noise it is possible to create level/time histories. For a Grid Noise Map these time histories can be used to create the picture of the instant noise level. These animations are saved to an AVI file such as the animation on the left of a military aircraft that fly over the airport, enter the pattern and then land.

As the instant noise level is taking the speed of sound into account, the diagrams assume strange shapes when the aircraft is flying on a curved path.

Noise from a Helicopter

The SoundPLAN aircraft noise module is ot only fit for the biggest airports (the Frankfurt, Germany airport has been modeled with SoundPLAN), is also used to model smaller fields where VFR operations and pattern traffic are the standard and it is used to show helicopter take-off and landing noise.

To the left you see typical scenarios for helicopter noise at a hospital. The top picture is the noise map on the ground; the next picture is the same thing in 3D with the buildings as solid objects. Noise map #3 is a cross-sectional noise map for a take-off. This track shows the helicopter back out of the landing pad and then assume regular flight.

In SoundPLAN the track is automatically generated from a few parameters like the departure direction, the elevation profile and the distance the helicopter "backs" out of the landing pad. The heli-pad is automatically set on top of the building. In contrast to regular aircraft noise, the screening of the building is regarded as in the near-field it has a significant influence on the noise levels generated by the helicopter.

 

  

SoundPLAN Hotline

SoundPLAN has a multi level hotline. If you have questions how the program is working, contact your local distributor for help. If the local distributor has questions, he contacts SoundPLAN International LLC and we and Braunstein + Berndt GmbH take it from there.

Sometimes we find the same or similar questions recur. We outline below some of these questions. If you have a topic you would like discussed, send an e-mail to support@soundplan.com. 

 

Vibrocomp ME FZC

United Arab Emirates

Contact Peter Farago

P.O. Box: 391860;  Dubai, UAE

Tel: (971) 52 7937216

e-mail: me@vibrocomp.com

New Distributor in the Persian Gulf

Vibrocomp, who has been the SoundPLAN distributor for Hungary and Romania, now also has an office in Dubai and will represent SoundPLAN in this region. Vibrocomp works in sales and marketing of SoundPLAN and offers consulting services for noise&vibration and air quality assessment.

See them at http://www.vibrocomp.com/

Installing Older SoundPLAN Version in Win8

When installing SoundPLAN or SoundPLAN Essential on a new PC with Win 7 or Win 8 it is paramount that you have the latest drivers. Only when the HASP driver is the latest version will the HASP copy protection key be recognized on the new PC. Learn more here:

http://www.soundplan.eu/english/soundplan-acoustics/soundplan-support/installing-soundplan/

Elevated Roadways Ė How? What?

Noise from elevated roadways causes problems for noise modeling as none of the existing standards fully address this situation. In SoundPLAN, roadways and elevated trains can be modeled as bridges where the edge of the structure acts as a noise barrier. To present the elevated structure, we modeled the pillars as a circle and converted the circle into the object type noise barrier and added a second element that was 25 degrees tilted. You see this to the left. We marked the group of "noise barriers," grabbed the group with the ALT key pressed, and then created copies of the pillars.

Sound Pressure - Sound Power

SoundPLAN industrial noise calculations require the entry of sound power levels. Users often have only the data of the sound pressure levels derived from their own measurements or taken from literature studies or provided by the manufacturer. Sound power is a characteristic of the source whereas the sound pressure level gives different answers if measured 1 meter, 7 meters or 25 meters from the source. Therefore sound pressure data need to be converted into sound power.

In SoundPLAN this conversion is easy. Set the data entry in the library to a reference of "level", enter the sound pressure spectrum and then right click on the spectrum to open the menu. Select "Convert sound pressure to sound power."

<">The program will present 4 different options to convert the data. For most cases with only a single measurement, the spherical model is the easiest. Enter the distance between the source and the measurement location and click on the "ok" button.

The reference will change to unit and the data are now the required sound power.

Quality of 3D Graphics

Sometimes when opening the 3D solid model in the SoundPLAN Graphics using "Edit Map," the picture will look crisp like in the upper screen capture but when the picture is printed the edges are jagged, the image is washed out and all in all it does not look as good as the top image. Why?

SoundPLAN uses OpenGL for the 3D solid models. OpenGL is part of the operating system, so it is available on every PC running a current version of Windows. OpenGL has a severe limitation! It is only set up to work with the screen. What is visible there is directly created with calls to OpenGL. As there is no printer driver that includes the 3D OpenGL data directly, we need to first generate a bitmap from the data we want to be included in our print. When leaving "Edit Map," you can choose the type of bitmap (jpeg, Tiff..) and the resolution and quality. If the quality of the bitmap is not sufficient, most likely it is a problem of the resolution of the bitmap. If the picture is not as crisp as you expected, increase the number of pixels per inch and you will see that the image quality will improve. To a lesser degree the compression will also make a difference. As nothing ever is for free, you will see that the higher the resolution is set, the bigger the bitmap will be that you include in the drawing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Other interesting phenomena occur in OpenGL itself. If you have a relatively big model, OpenGL can run into resolution problems in the 3D rendering. If the area is big, OpenGL at one time can no longer make the correct decision what object is in the foreground and what is covered by other objects. To the left you see an example of this. The top screen capture was done with the standard setting where the nearest clip plane was set to 2 meters. As the area for the entire bitmap was huge, this setting proved insufficient and the result is a mess.

By increasing the parameter for the nearest clip plane to 7 meters, the lower picture shows what we expected.

Air Absorption for Industry Noise

The scenario was one point source with a third octave spectrum between 25 Hz and 20 kHz. The distance chosen was very big in order to show the effect of the air absorption. For the calculation a protocol was generated and the table exported to Excel.

The first column is the frequency the second column is the air absorption in accordance to ISO 1913, the third column is the air absorption in accordance to ANSI 126 and the last column shows the results in accordance to ISO 3891. ISO 9613 and ISO 3891 are close enough that we can explain the differences with environmental parameters. The results for ANSI 126 however really look strange! Why

ANSI 126 is an ancient standard based on a value table that was set up for octave bands so all third octaves of the octave band use the same values. As there are no values in the table for frequencies beyond 8 kHz, we use the values for 8 kHz. If this is not enough, our advice is to use the ISO 9613!

Like many other software products, developments continue and additional features and methods become available. Being aware of and making use of these developments is highly recommended. Keep licenses up to date with Update & Maintenance (U+M), where not only hot line support is available, but also regular updates via the website. Knowledge also needs updating once in a while, and that can be achieved via training sessions.

SoundPLAN and many of our trading partners offer regular training sessions for beginners and seasoned users. David Winterbottom in the UK, John Klinkby in Denmark and Hans Forschner in the US offer regular training sessions. If you are interested in learning more, use the links to the right to learn training dates and locations and to ask for further details. SoundPLAN offers training sessions in  Backnang, Germany. Click here to download the SoundPLAN training schedule for 2014.

Copyright 2014 SoundPLAN International LLC; 80 E Aspley Ln; Shelton, WA 98584; USA

If you do not want to receive more SoundPLAN Info, click this link